Workplace Risk Assessment Process and HSE Guidance
Risk Assessment in Brief
Identify hazards, decide who could be harmed and how, evaluate the risks and decide on precautions. Record the significant findings if you employ five or more people. Review when things change or after an incident.
Risk Assessment
Risk assessment is the process of identifying hazards - things that could cause harm - evaluating the risk they present, and deciding what controls to put in place to bring that risk to an acceptable level. It is the central activity of practical health and safety management. Policies, procedures, training, inspections and incident investigations all exist to support the conclusions reached in risk assessment, or to respond when those conclusions turn out to be wrong.
In the UK, a risk assessment is a legal requirement under regulation 3 of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999. Every employer must assess the risks to workers and to others who may be affected by their work. Where five or more employees are on the payroll, the significant findings of the assessment must be recorded. The form the record takes is not prescribed - what matters is that it is suitable and sufficient for the risks involved.
The Five Steps to Risk Assessment
The UK's Health and Safety Executive (HSE) has long promoted a five-step approach to risk assessment that matches how most practitioners actually work:
- Identify the hazards - walk the job, talk to the people doing it, review incident records, and look at what else has gone wrong in similar work
- Decide who might be harmed and how - workers, visitors, contractors, members of the public, and think about people with specific vulnerabilities (new or expectant mothers, young workers, lone workers)
- Evaluate the risks and decide on controls - consider what is already in place, whether more is reasonably practicable, and work through the hierarchy of control from elimination through to PPE
- Record the significant findings - enough to show what was considered and what was decided, proportionate to the risk
- Review and update - when the work changes, when controls fail, after incidents, and periodically as a backstop
The HSE stopped calling it the five-step approach in their current guidance in favour of a more flexible description, but the underlying process is the same and most risk assessment templates follow this structure. What matters is that the assessment is useful to the people who have to work with it, not that it matches a particular template.
Hazards and Risks - The Difference
These two words get used interchangeably, but they are not the same thing. A hazard is something with the potential to cause harm - a chemical, a piece of equipment, a working environment, a way of doing a task. A risk is the combination of the likelihood that the hazard will cause harm and the severity of that harm if it does.
That distinction matters because you control risk, not hazard. Electricity will always be a hazard; you manage it through insulation, fuses, training, competent persons and inspection. Working at height will always be a hazard; you manage it through eliminating the need where possible, using guarded access where not, and providing fall arrest where neither is feasible.
The Hierarchy of Control
When deciding on controls, the hierarchy of control tells you the order to consider options in:
- Elimination - remove the hazard entirely by redesigning the work
- Substitution - replace the hazard with something less dangerous
- Engineering controls - physical controls that reduce exposure - guards, extraction, sound insulation, barriers
- Administrative controls - procedures, training, signage, permits, job rotation
- Personal protective equipment - the last line of defence, used in addition to higher controls rather than instead of them
The hierarchy is not a menu to pick from. Higher-level controls should be exhausted before moving down. PPE is not a substitute for extraction; training is not a substitute for guarding. Skipping levels is a common weakness in risk assessments that relies on PPE or procedure where engineering controls are practicable.
Types of Risk Assessment
Most organisations end up with several types of risk assessment, each covering a different scope:
- General or activity-based - covers recurring activities such as office work, driving, working with the public
- Task-based - covers specific tasks with their own hazard profile, such as operating a particular machine
- Site-based - covers a specific workplace and the hazards inherent to it
- COSHH - required separately under the Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations for each hazardous substance used
- Fire risk assessment - required under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 for premises the organisation has control over
- DSE - required for users of display screen equipment under the DSE Regulations 1992
- Manual handling - required under the Manual Handling Operations Regulations 1992 where hazardous manual handling is involved
- Specific individuals - new and expectant mothers, young workers, lone workers and others with heightened vulnerability
- Dynamic - on-the-spot assessments for work that varies too much to be covered by a written assessment alone
This list is not a set of boxes to tick. Assess what you actually have - a small consultancy has a handful; a manufacturing site with chemical processes, heavy plant and construction interfaces has many. The assessments should reflect the work, not fill a template.
Method Statements and RAMS
For higher-risk tasks, a risk assessment is often paired with a method statement setting out the safe system of work step by step - a risk assessment and method statement, commonly referred to as a RAMS. RAMS are widely used in construction, maintenance and other higher-risk work where a single risk assessment alone would not give workers enough detail on how to carry out the task.
A method statement describes what will be done, in what order, by whom, with what equipment and with what controls. It turns the risk assessment's conclusions into a practical sequence the worker can follow. Most organisations keep them as separate documents that are read together; some integrate them into a single RAMS document.
Reviewing Risk Assessments
A risk assessment that never gets reviewed is a risk assessment that becomes wrong. Reviews should happen:
- When the work, equipment, people or environment change materially
- When an incident shows the controls are not working
- When legislation or guidance changes in a way that affects the assessment
- When a worker raises a concern that the assessment does not cover
- Periodically as a backstop - annually is common, though frequency should be proportionate to the risk and the rate of change
Dated reviews showing who looked at the assessment and what they changed are the evidence that the system is live rather than filed. An assessment with a review date three years in the past tells an auditor more than the content of the assessment itself.
The biggest problem I see with risk assessments is that they are written for filing, not for using. The format looks plausible, the hazards are listed, the controls sound reasonable - but the workers doing the job have never seen the document, have no idea it exists, and the controls on it are things that have never been put in place.
My test is simple. Pick a named risk assessment at random and ask the worker who does the task what it says. If they can summarise the hazards and the controls, the assessment is working. If they have not seen it, the assessment is just paperwork.
The other trap is over-assessment. Seventeen separate risk assessments for activities that could be covered by three. Every one has to be maintained, reviewed, communicated. Fewer, better assessments beat more, worse ones.
Risk assessment is not a dark art. You walk the job with someone who knows it, you ask what could go wrong, you write down what you agree to do about it, and you check later whether that worked. Anyone telling you it is more complicated than that is selling something.
We went through our risk assessments about three years ago and cut the number in half. The ones we removed were either duplicates, covered hazards we did not actually have, or so generic they were not useful.
The ones that survived got rewritten with input from the people doing the work. They are shorter, they are current, and people use them.
Practical Compliance Guidance
Risk assessment is covered within the operational planning and control arrangements in the IMS1 Manual, supported by a set of alphaZ risk assessment forms, registers and guidance covering the common risk assessment types most organisations need.
The documents below cover the core risk assessment templates, the hazard register that tracks them, and the method statement templates often paired with higher-risk work. Other specific risk assessment types (COSHH, DSE, fire, manual handling) are covered in the articles on those topics.
| alphaZ document | How to use it |
|---|---|
| ISO 9001, 14001 and 45001 IMS Toolkit | Full integrated management system toolkit containing the risk assessment documents listed below alongside the wider management system templates. |
| Risk Assessment Toolkit | Focused toolkit bringing together the risk assessment templates, hazard prompts and method statement forms in one place. |
| ER14 Hazard and Risk Assessment Register | Register for tracking all hazards identified and the risk assessments that cover them, so the full set can be managed and reviewed. |
| F-HS20 General Risk Assessment | Template for general and activity-based risk assessments covering the recurring hazards most workplaces encounter. |
| F-HS21 Site Risk Assessment | Template for site-specific risk assessments covering the hazards inherent to a particular location or site. |
| F-HS14 Task Risk Assessment | Template for task-specific risk assessments covering individual tasks or operations with their own distinct hazard profile. |
| F-HS3 Risk Assessment Hazard Prompt | Prompt sheet listing common workplace hazards to help identify what should be considered when completing a risk assessment. |
| F-HS29 Risk Assessment and Method Statement (RAMS) | Combined RAMS template pairing a risk assessment with a method statement - commonly used for construction and higher-risk work. |
| Toolbox Talk - Completing a Risk Assessment | Short training talk on risk assessment principles, suitable for briefing workers involved in completing or reviewing risk assessments. |
Note - all the above files can be downloaded with an alphaZ subscription.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do risk assessments have to be written down?
In the UK, employers with five or more employees must record the significant findings of their risk assessments. Smaller employers are not required to write them down but are still required to carry them out and to be able to demonstrate that they have. In practice, even small employers are usually better off with written assessments - they are simpler to review and more defensible if ever challenged.
How detailed should a risk assessment be?
Proportionate to the risk. A low-risk office activity can be covered in a short document; a high-risk construction activity may need a detailed RAMS. The legal test is whether the assessment is "suitable and sufficient" - detailed enough that the significant hazards and the controls are clearly identified. More detail than that is usually wasted effort.
Can a risk assessment be generic?
A generic assessment can be a useful starting point for activities that are genuinely the same across many sites or tasks - office work, use of standard equipment. But a generic assessment on its own is rarely suitable and sufficient for site-specific or task-specific work. The assessment should be reviewed and adapted to the actual conditions, with those adaptations recorded.
Who should carry out risk assessments?
Someone competent to do so - meaning someone with the training, knowledge and experience relevant to the work and the hazards. For office-based risks, a trained manager or team leader is usually sufficient. For higher-risk work, specialist input may be needed. The people doing the work should always be involved, either in completing the assessment or in reviewing it.
UK Legislation
The following UK legislation is directly relevant to risk assessment. Organisations outside the UK should identify the equivalent legislation applicable in their jurisdiction.
- Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974
- Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999
- Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations 2002
- Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005
- Manual Handling Operations Regulations 1992
