Cookie Catastrophe: The New PECR Fines

Until 5 February 2026, a fine for getting cookies wrong was capped at £500,000, and the ICO could only issue one where a breach was serious and likely to cause substantial damage or substantial distress. The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 changed both. PECR fines now reach £17.5 million or 4% of global annual turnover, whichever is higher, the same maximum as the UK GDPR, and a breach no longer has to be serious or cause substantial damage or distress to be fined. That is the cookie catastrophe: not the size of the number, but how little it now takes to be within range of it.
PECR Fines and the Cookie Rules
The rule itself is simple. Nothing may be stored on a visitor's device, or read from it, without consent unless an exception applies, and that covers tracking pixels, local storage and device fingerprinting as well as cookies. The site owner answers for everything the site causes to be set: tags added by a marketing agency, tools loaded by a plugin, and embedded videos, maps and social feeds that set their own cookies when the page opens. A contract with the agency shares the work, not the responsibility. The same maximum applies to marketing emails, texts and calls sent in breach of PECR. Our knowledge base article on cookies and electronic marketing under PECR sets out the rules in full.
Cookie Banners That Invite PECR Fines
A cookie banner only counts if it works. Nothing that needs consent can be set before the visitor chooses, rejecting has to be as easy as accepting, nothing can be pre-ticked, nothing can be set after a refusal, and the visitor has to be able to change their mind later. Continuing to browse is not consent, and nor is a notice saying cookies are used that offers no choice.
The easiest way to fail is a banner that sits on screen while the tracking loads behind it anyway, whatever the visitor clicks. When the ICO tested the UK's top 1,000 websites in 2025, more than half only passed after the ICO stepped in. Those are the best-resourced websites in the country, so a small business website nobody has checked since it was built deserves a look.
PECR Fines and the New Cookie Exemptions
The Act eased the rules as well. Consent is not needed for cookies used only to gather statistics that improve the website, only to remember how a visitor wants the site to look or work, or only to provide emergency assistance. For statistics and appearance, visitors must be told what is used and given a simple, free way to object. The word doing the work is "only". An analytics tool that also feeds advertising, builds visitor profiles or passes data to its provider for the provider's own use still needs consent, and advertising always does.
Avoiding PECR Fines on Your Own Website
Open the site in a private browser window, reject everything on the banner, and look at the cookies the browser has stored (in Chrome, Developer tools, then the Application tab). If analytics or advertising cookies are there, the banner isn't working, however good it looks. Then find out who added each tag and whether the cookie policy lists it.
On isomanaged.com, no analytics or advertising cookie is set until a visitor says yes, declining sets none, and the Cookie Settings link in every footer lets the choice be changed at any time. The privacy policy lists each cookie by name, purpose and how long it lasts. For organisations with a management system, PECR sits on the legal register alongside the UK GDPR, and a periodic check of the website and marketing lists is the practical way to evaluate compliance with it.
Legal and Compliance Knowledge Base
Cookies and Electronic Marketing (PECR)
Published: 11 November 2026